Optimal Thresholds for the Estimation of Area Rain-Rate Moments by the Threshold Method

David A. Short Laboratory for Atmospheres, NASA/GSFC, Greenbelt, Maryland

Search for other papers by David A. Short in
Current site
Google Scholar
PubMed
Close
,
Kunio Shimizu Department of Applied Mathematics, Science University of Tokyo, Tokyo, Japan

Search for other papers by Kunio Shimizu in
Current site
Google Scholar
PubMed
Close
, and
Benjamin Kedem Department of Mathematics, University of Maryland, College Park. Maryland

Search for other papers by Benjamin Kedem in
Current site
Google Scholar
PubMed
Close
Restricted access

Abstract

Optimization of the threshold method, achieved by determination of the threshold that maximizes the correlation between an area-average rain-rate moment and the area coverage of rain rates exceeding the threshold, is demonstrated empirically and theoretically. Empirical results for a sequence of GATE radar snapshots show optimal thresholds of 5 and 27 mm h−1 for the first and second moments, respectively. Theoretical optimization of the threshold method by the maximum-likelihood approach of Kedem and Pavlopoulos predicts optimal thresholds near 5 and 26 mm h−1 for lognormally distributed rain rates with GATE-like parameters. The agreement between theory and observations suggests that the optimal threshold can be understood as arising due to sampling variations, from snapshot to snapshot, of a parent rain-rate distribution. Optimal thresholds for gamma and inverse Gaussian distributions are also derived and compared

Abstract

Optimization of the threshold method, achieved by determination of the threshold that maximizes the correlation between an area-average rain-rate moment and the area coverage of rain rates exceeding the threshold, is demonstrated empirically and theoretically. Empirical results for a sequence of GATE radar snapshots show optimal thresholds of 5 and 27 mm h−1 for the first and second moments, respectively. Theoretical optimization of the threshold method by the maximum-likelihood approach of Kedem and Pavlopoulos predicts optimal thresholds near 5 and 26 mm h−1 for lognormally distributed rain rates with GATE-like parameters. The agreement between theory and observations suggests that the optimal threshold can be understood as arising due to sampling variations, from snapshot to snapshot, of a parent rain-rate distribution. Optimal thresholds for gamma and inverse Gaussian distributions are also derived and compared

Save