Browse
Abstract
Flash flooding is the most damaging and deadly type of flooding event in the continental United States (CONUS), and one of the deadliest hazards worldwide. The Weather Prediction Center’s (WPC) Excessive Rainfall Outlook (ERO) is used to highlight regions at risk of receiving excessive rainfall that can lead to flash flooding. While EROs have been validated by the WPC across several metrics, an analysis of flash floods that were not forecast by EROs, which we define as missed flash floods, has not been performed, nor have damages associated with missed flash floods been examined. Using EROs, flash flood data from the Unified Flooding Verification System (UFVS), and flash flood damage data from the National Centers for Environmental Information (NCEI) Storm Events Database, this research investigates the characteristics of missed flash floods. We find that missed damages occur most frequently in summer and least frequently in winter, but that only 9.2% of flash flood damages and 23.2% of damaging events are missed by the ERO. Missed damaging flash flood events occur frequently in the U.S. Southwest. In this region, missed damages and missed events are primarily attributed to the North American monsoon (NAM). We also investigate forecast flash floods by ERO risk category. High risks incur the most damages despite having the fewest number of damaging events, indicating that the ERO is able to distinguish higher-impact events. The ERO predicts damaging flash floods well, although the Southwest and urban areas broadly could be investigated further to ensure that the potential of damaging flash floods are accurately forecast.
Abstract
Flash flooding is the most damaging and deadly type of flooding event in the continental United States (CONUS), and one of the deadliest hazards worldwide. The Weather Prediction Center’s (WPC) Excessive Rainfall Outlook (ERO) is used to highlight regions at risk of receiving excessive rainfall that can lead to flash flooding. While EROs have been validated by the WPC across several metrics, an analysis of flash floods that were not forecast by EROs, which we define as missed flash floods, has not been performed, nor have damages associated with missed flash floods been examined. Using EROs, flash flood data from the Unified Flooding Verification System (UFVS), and flash flood damage data from the National Centers for Environmental Information (NCEI) Storm Events Database, this research investigates the characteristics of missed flash floods. We find that missed damages occur most frequently in summer and least frequently in winter, but that only 9.2% of flash flood damages and 23.2% of damaging events are missed by the ERO. Missed damaging flash flood events occur frequently in the U.S. Southwest. In this region, missed damages and missed events are primarily attributed to the North American monsoon (NAM). We also investigate forecast flash floods by ERO risk category. High risks incur the most damages despite having the fewest number of damaging events, indicating that the ERO is able to distinguish higher-impact events. The ERO predicts damaging flash floods well, although the Southwest and urban areas broadly could be investigated further to ensure that the potential of damaging flash floods are accurately forecast.
Abstract
The seasonal predictability of the Rossby wave breaking (RWB) frequency near Japan in July–August (JA) is examined using daily JMA/MRI-CPS3 (CPS3) hindcast data, which is an operational seasonal prediction system of the Japan Meteorological Agency. Although the RWB frequency near Japan during JA in CPS3 is underestimated in comparison with the reanalysis, interannual variabilities of the frequency are generally predicted with moderate or high skill for hindcasts, initiating from February to June. The RWB frequency forecast skill in CPS3 is much higher than that in the previous version of the seasonal prediction system due to the improvement in the model bias of the Asian jet stream meridional position. A regression analysis for the RWB frequency near Japan utilizing all ensemble members is conducted to evaluate the reproducibility of the increased (decreased) RWB frequency associated with La Niña (El Niño) conditions, as indicated by previous studies. The regressed anomalies demonstrate an anomalous sea surface temperature (SST) pattern similar to that of La Niña and a negative phase of the Indian Ocean dipole mode with the associated anomalous convection in the tropics. For the La Niña condition, the regressed geopotential height in the upper troposphere demonstrates negative anomalies over the tropical Pacific and positive anomalies in the extratropical Northern Hemisphere, corresponding to the enhanced mid-Pacific trough and northward-shifted subtropical jet. The regressed meridional wind anomalies demonstrate a wavy pattern along the Asian jet over Eurasia, consistent with the relationship between the Silk Road pattern and the RWB near the Asian jet exit region.
Abstract
The seasonal predictability of the Rossby wave breaking (RWB) frequency near Japan in July–August (JA) is examined using daily JMA/MRI-CPS3 (CPS3) hindcast data, which is an operational seasonal prediction system of the Japan Meteorological Agency. Although the RWB frequency near Japan during JA in CPS3 is underestimated in comparison with the reanalysis, interannual variabilities of the frequency are generally predicted with moderate or high skill for hindcasts, initiating from February to June. The RWB frequency forecast skill in CPS3 is much higher than that in the previous version of the seasonal prediction system due to the improvement in the model bias of the Asian jet stream meridional position. A regression analysis for the RWB frequency near Japan utilizing all ensemble members is conducted to evaluate the reproducibility of the increased (decreased) RWB frequency associated with La Niña (El Niño) conditions, as indicated by previous studies. The regressed anomalies demonstrate an anomalous sea surface temperature (SST) pattern similar to that of La Niña and a negative phase of the Indian Ocean dipole mode with the associated anomalous convection in the tropics. For the La Niña condition, the regressed geopotential height in the upper troposphere demonstrates negative anomalies over the tropical Pacific and positive anomalies in the extratropical Northern Hemisphere, corresponding to the enhanced mid-Pacific trough and northward-shifted subtropical jet. The regressed meridional wind anomalies demonstrate a wavy pattern along the Asian jet over Eurasia, consistent with the relationship between the Silk Road pattern and the RWB near the Asian jet exit region.
Abstract
Because geostationary satellite (Geo) imagery provides a high temporal resolution window into tropical cyclone (TC) behavior, we investigate the viability of its application to short-term probabilistic forecasts of TC convective structure to subsequently predict TC intensity. Here, we present a prototype model that is trained solely on two inputs: Geo infrared imagery leading up to the synoptic time of interest and intensity estimates up to 6 h prior to that time. To estimate future TC structure, we compute cloud-top temperature radial profiles from infrared imagery and then simulate the evolution of an ensemble of those profiles over the subsequent 12 h by applying a deep autoregressive generative model (PixelSNAIL). To forecast TC intensities at hours 6 and 12, we input operational intensity estimates up to the current time (0 h) and simulated future radial profiles up to +12 h into a “nowcasting” convolutional neural network. We limit our inputs to demonstrate the viability of our approach and to enable quantification of value added by the observed and simulated future radial profiles beyond operational intensity estimates alone. Our prototype model achieves a marginally higher error than the National Hurricane Center’s official forecasts despite excluding environmental factors, such as vertical wind shear and sea surface temperature. We also demonstrate that it is possible to reasonably predict short-term evolution of TC convective structure via radial profiles from Geo infrared imagery, resulting in interpretable structural forecasts that may be valuable for TC operational guidance.
Significance Statement
This work presents a new method of short-term probabilistic forecasting for tropical cyclone (TC) convective structure and intensity using infrared geostationary satellite observations. Our prototype model’s performance indicates that there is some value in observed and simulated future cloud-top temperature radial profiles for short-term intensity forecasting. The nonlinear nature of machine learning tools can pose an interpretation challenge, but structural forecasts produced by our model can be directly evaluated and, thus, may offer helpful guidance to forecasters regarding short-term TC evolution. Since forecasters are time limited in producing each advisory package despite a growing wealth of satellite observations, a tool that captures recent TC convective evolution and potential future changes may support their assessment of TC behavior in crafting their forecasts.
Abstract
Because geostationary satellite (Geo) imagery provides a high temporal resolution window into tropical cyclone (TC) behavior, we investigate the viability of its application to short-term probabilistic forecasts of TC convective structure to subsequently predict TC intensity. Here, we present a prototype model that is trained solely on two inputs: Geo infrared imagery leading up to the synoptic time of interest and intensity estimates up to 6 h prior to that time. To estimate future TC structure, we compute cloud-top temperature radial profiles from infrared imagery and then simulate the evolution of an ensemble of those profiles over the subsequent 12 h by applying a deep autoregressive generative model (PixelSNAIL). To forecast TC intensities at hours 6 and 12, we input operational intensity estimates up to the current time (0 h) and simulated future radial profiles up to +12 h into a “nowcasting” convolutional neural network. We limit our inputs to demonstrate the viability of our approach and to enable quantification of value added by the observed and simulated future radial profiles beyond operational intensity estimates alone. Our prototype model achieves a marginally higher error than the National Hurricane Center’s official forecasts despite excluding environmental factors, such as vertical wind shear and sea surface temperature. We also demonstrate that it is possible to reasonably predict short-term evolution of TC convective structure via radial profiles from Geo infrared imagery, resulting in interpretable structural forecasts that may be valuable for TC operational guidance.
Significance Statement
This work presents a new method of short-term probabilistic forecasting for tropical cyclone (TC) convective structure and intensity using infrared geostationary satellite observations. Our prototype model’s performance indicates that there is some value in observed and simulated future cloud-top temperature radial profiles for short-term intensity forecasting. The nonlinear nature of machine learning tools can pose an interpretation challenge, but structural forecasts produced by our model can be directly evaluated and, thus, may offer helpful guidance to forecasters regarding short-term TC evolution. Since forecasters are time limited in producing each advisory package despite a growing wealth of satellite observations, a tool that captures recent TC convective evolution and potential future changes may support their assessment of TC behavior in crafting their forecasts.
Abstract
Urban heat islands (UHIs) may increase the likelihood that frost sensitive plants will escape freezing nighttime temperatures in late spring and early fall. Using data from 151 temperature sensors in the Madison, Wisconsin, region during March 2012–October 2016, we found that during time periods when the National Weather Service (NWS) issued freeze warnings (threshold of 0.0°C) or frost advisories (threshold of 2.22°C) were valid, temperatures in Madison’s most densely populated, built-up areas often did not fall below the respective temperature thresholds. Urban locations had a mean minimum temperature of 0.72° and 1.39°C for spring and fall freeze warnings, respectively, compared to −0.52° and −0.53°C for rural locations. On average, 31% of the region’s land area experienced minimum temperatures above the respective temperature thresholds during freeze warnings and frost advisories, and the likelihood of temperatures falling below critical temperature thresholds increased as the distance away from core urban centers increased. The urban–rural temperature differences were greatest in fall compared to spring, and when sensor temperatures did drop below thresholds, the maximum time spent at or below thresholds was highest for rural locations during fall freeze warnings (6.2 h) compared to urban locations (4.8 h). These findings potentially have widely varying implications for the general public and industry. UHIs create localized, positive perturbations to nighttime temperatures that are difficult to account for in forecasts; therefore, freeze warnings and frost advisories may have varying degrees of verification in medium-sized cities like Madison, Wisconsin, that are surrounded by cropland and natural vegetation.
Significance Statement
The purpose of this study was to understand whether the urban heat island effect in Madison, Wisconsin, creates localized temperature patterns where county-scale frost advisories and freeze warnings may not verify. Approximately one-third of Madison’s urban core area and most densely populated region experienced temperatures that were consistently above critical low temperature thresholds. This is important because gardening and crop management decisions are responsive to the perceived risk of cold temperatures in spring and fall that can damage or kill plants. These results suggest that urban warming presents forecast challenges to the issuance of frost advisories and freeze warnings, supporting the need for improved numerical weather prediction at higher spatial resolution to account for complex urban meteorology.
Abstract
Urban heat islands (UHIs) may increase the likelihood that frost sensitive plants will escape freezing nighttime temperatures in late spring and early fall. Using data from 151 temperature sensors in the Madison, Wisconsin, region during March 2012–October 2016, we found that during time periods when the National Weather Service (NWS) issued freeze warnings (threshold of 0.0°C) or frost advisories (threshold of 2.22°C) were valid, temperatures in Madison’s most densely populated, built-up areas often did not fall below the respective temperature thresholds. Urban locations had a mean minimum temperature of 0.72° and 1.39°C for spring and fall freeze warnings, respectively, compared to −0.52° and −0.53°C for rural locations. On average, 31% of the region’s land area experienced minimum temperatures above the respective temperature thresholds during freeze warnings and frost advisories, and the likelihood of temperatures falling below critical temperature thresholds increased as the distance away from core urban centers increased. The urban–rural temperature differences were greatest in fall compared to spring, and when sensor temperatures did drop below thresholds, the maximum time spent at or below thresholds was highest for rural locations during fall freeze warnings (6.2 h) compared to urban locations (4.8 h). These findings potentially have widely varying implications for the general public and industry. UHIs create localized, positive perturbations to nighttime temperatures that are difficult to account for in forecasts; therefore, freeze warnings and frost advisories may have varying degrees of verification in medium-sized cities like Madison, Wisconsin, that are surrounded by cropland and natural vegetation.
Significance Statement
The purpose of this study was to understand whether the urban heat island effect in Madison, Wisconsin, creates localized temperature patterns where county-scale frost advisories and freeze warnings may not verify. Approximately one-third of Madison’s urban core area and most densely populated region experienced temperatures that were consistently above critical low temperature thresholds. This is important because gardening and crop management decisions are responsive to the perceived risk of cold temperatures in spring and fall that can damage or kill plants. These results suggest that urban warming presents forecast challenges to the issuance of frost advisories and freeze warnings, supporting the need for improved numerical weather prediction at higher spatial resolution to account for complex urban meteorology.
Abstract
This work assesses the contribution of assimilating AMSU-A satellite-based radiance measurements to a global data assimilation system based on an atmospheric general circulation model and the local ensemble transform Kalman filter (LETKF). The radiance measurements were from three channels that are sensitive to the upper troposphere and lower stratosphere. The contribution of these measurements, or AMSU-A observation impact, was estimated both through ensemble-based forecast sensitivity to observations (EFSO) and observing system experiments (OSEs). Two streams of data-denial experiments for the AMSU-A observations were performed for about one month during winter in each hemisphere. The OSEs quantified the accumulated observation impact by cycling (repeating) data denials: including AMSU-A observations reduced the total observation impact for all observations of each data assimilation cycle. In contrast, EFSO estimated AMSU-A to increase the total observation impact. The opposing effects were attributed to the accumulated observation impact in the OSEs; the accumulation could stabilize the data assimilation cycles. In both experiments, the accumulated observation impact of AMSU-A was strongest in the upper troposphere, particularly in the austral midlatitudes where westerly jets exist and observations of other types are sparse. EFSO also assessed AMSU-A to have the most beneficial observation impact in similar locations. The AMSU-A observation impact tended to accumulate just downstream of where EFSO estimated the beneficial observation impact signals. The accumulated AMSU-A observation impact was tied to dynamic processes in the upper-tropospheric and general stratospheric circulation. Therefore, EFSO helps estimate the beneficial distributions of AMSU-A accumulated observation impact by considering their dynamical propagation.
Significance Statement
The Advanced Microwave Sounding Unit-A (AMSU-A) satellite radiance assimilation technique was successfully integrated into the Atmospheric General Circulation Model for the Earth Simulator (AFES)–LETKF data assimilation system. We conducted OSEs and used EFSO to assess the AMSU-A observation impact. The two estimation methods identified opposite observation impacts due to the cycling (repeating) OSEs of the AMSU-A observations. We interpreted the causes of the opposite estimations. However, even for the cycling OSEs, EFSO appeared to help estimate distributions of the accumulated observation impact. It is important to consider the dynamical propagation of accumulated observation impact in general circulation.
Abstract
This work assesses the contribution of assimilating AMSU-A satellite-based radiance measurements to a global data assimilation system based on an atmospheric general circulation model and the local ensemble transform Kalman filter (LETKF). The radiance measurements were from three channels that are sensitive to the upper troposphere and lower stratosphere. The contribution of these measurements, or AMSU-A observation impact, was estimated both through ensemble-based forecast sensitivity to observations (EFSO) and observing system experiments (OSEs). Two streams of data-denial experiments for the AMSU-A observations were performed for about one month during winter in each hemisphere. The OSEs quantified the accumulated observation impact by cycling (repeating) data denials: including AMSU-A observations reduced the total observation impact for all observations of each data assimilation cycle. In contrast, EFSO estimated AMSU-A to increase the total observation impact. The opposing effects were attributed to the accumulated observation impact in the OSEs; the accumulation could stabilize the data assimilation cycles. In both experiments, the accumulated observation impact of AMSU-A was strongest in the upper troposphere, particularly in the austral midlatitudes where westerly jets exist and observations of other types are sparse. EFSO also assessed AMSU-A to have the most beneficial observation impact in similar locations. The AMSU-A observation impact tended to accumulate just downstream of where EFSO estimated the beneficial observation impact signals. The accumulated AMSU-A observation impact was tied to dynamic processes in the upper-tropospheric and general stratospheric circulation. Therefore, EFSO helps estimate the beneficial distributions of AMSU-A accumulated observation impact by considering their dynamical propagation.
Significance Statement
The Advanced Microwave Sounding Unit-A (AMSU-A) satellite radiance assimilation technique was successfully integrated into the Atmospheric General Circulation Model for the Earth Simulator (AFES)–LETKF data assimilation system. We conducted OSEs and used EFSO to assess the AMSU-A observation impact. The two estimation methods identified opposite observation impacts due to the cycling (repeating) OSEs of the AMSU-A observations. We interpreted the causes of the opposite estimations. However, even for the cycling OSEs, EFSO appeared to help estimate distributions of the accumulated observation impact. It is important to consider the dynamical propagation of accumulated observation impact in general circulation.
Abstract
This work investigates the impact of tropical sea surface temperature (SST) biases on the Subseasonal to Seasonal Prediction project (S2S) precipitation forecast skill over the contiguous United States (CONUS) in the Unified Forecast System (UFS) coupled model Prototype 6. Boreal summer (June–September) and winter (December–March) for 2011–18 were analyzed. The impact of tropical west Pacific (WP) and tropical North Atlantic (TNA) warm SST biases is evaluated using multivariate linear regression analysis. A warm SST bias over the WP influences the CONUS precipitation remotely through a Rossby wave train in both seasons. During boreal winter, a warm SST bias over the TNA partly affects the magnitude of the North Atlantic subtropical high (NASH)’s center, which in the reforecasts is weaker than in reanalysis. The weaker NASH favors an enhanced moisture transport from the Gulf of Mexico, leading to increased precipitation over the Southeast United States. Compared to reanalysis, during boreal summer, the NASH’s center is also weaker and in addition, its position is displaced to the northeast. The displacement further affects the CONUS summer precipitation. The SST biases over the two tropical regions and their impacts become stronger as the forecast lead increases from week 1 to 4. These tropical biases explain up to 10% of the CONUS precipitation biases on the S2S time scale.
Abstract
This work investigates the impact of tropical sea surface temperature (SST) biases on the Subseasonal to Seasonal Prediction project (S2S) precipitation forecast skill over the contiguous United States (CONUS) in the Unified Forecast System (UFS) coupled model Prototype 6. Boreal summer (June–September) and winter (December–March) for 2011–18 were analyzed. The impact of tropical west Pacific (WP) and tropical North Atlantic (TNA) warm SST biases is evaluated using multivariate linear regression analysis. A warm SST bias over the WP influences the CONUS precipitation remotely through a Rossby wave train in both seasons. During boreal winter, a warm SST bias over the TNA partly affects the magnitude of the North Atlantic subtropical high (NASH)’s center, which in the reforecasts is weaker than in reanalysis. The weaker NASH favors an enhanced moisture transport from the Gulf of Mexico, leading to increased precipitation over the Southeast United States. Compared to reanalysis, during boreal summer, the NASH’s center is also weaker and in addition, its position is displaced to the northeast. The displacement further affects the CONUS summer precipitation. The SST biases over the two tropical regions and their impacts become stronger as the forecast lead increases from week 1 to 4. These tropical biases explain up to 10% of the CONUS precipitation biases on the S2S time scale.
Abstract
A global multimodel probabilistic subseasonal forecast system for precipitation and near-surface temperature is developed based on three NOAA ensemble prediction systems that make their forecasts available publicly in real time as part of the Subseasonal Experiment (SubX). The weekly and biweekly ensemble means of precipitation and temperature of each model are individually calibrated at each grid point using extended logistic regression, prior to forming equal-weighted multimodel ensemble (MME) probabilistic forecasts. Reforecast skill of week-3–4 precipitation and temperature is assessed in terms of the cross-validated ranked probability skill score (RPSS) and reliability diagram. The multimodel reforecasts are shown to be well calibrated for both variables. Precipitation is moderately skillful over many tropical land regions, including Latin America, sub-Saharan Africa and Southeast Asia, and over subtropical South America, Africa, and Australia. Near-surface temperature skill is considerably higher than for precipitation and extends into the extratropics as well. The multimodel RPSS skill of both precipitation and temperature is shown to exceed that of any of the constituent models over Indonesia, South Asia, South America, and East Africa in all seasons. An example real-time week-3–4 global forecast for 13–26 November 2021 is illustrated and shown to bear the hallmarks of the combined influences of a moderate Madden–Julian oscillation event as well as weak–moderate ongoing La Niña event.
Significance Statement
This paper develops a system for forecasting of precipitation and temperatures globally over land, several weeks in advance, with a focus on biweekly averaged conditions between three and four weeks ahead. The system provides the likelihood of biweekly and weekly conditions being below, near, or above their long-term averages, as well the probability of exceeding (or not exceeding) any threshold value. Using historical data, the precipitation forecasts are demonstrated to have skill in many tropical regions, and the temperature forecasts are more widely skillful. While weather and seasonal range forecasts have become quite generally available, this is one of the first examples of a publicly available, calibrated multimodel probabilistic real-time forecasting system for the subseasonal range.
Abstract
A global multimodel probabilistic subseasonal forecast system for precipitation and near-surface temperature is developed based on three NOAA ensemble prediction systems that make their forecasts available publicly in real time as part of the Subseasonal Experiment (SubX). The weekly and biweekly ensemble means of precipitation and temperature of each model are individually calibrated at each grid point using extended logistic regression, prior to forming equal-weighted multimodel ensemble (MME) probabilistic forecasts. Reforecast skill of week-3–4 precipitation and temperature is assessed in terms of the cross-validated ranked probability skill score (RPSS) and reliability diagram. The multimodel reforecasts are shown to be well calibrated for both variables. Precipitation is moderately skillful over many tropical land regions, including Latin America, sub-Saharan Africa and Southeast Asia, and over subtropical South America, Africa, and Australia. Near-surface temperature skill is considerably higher than for precipitation and extends into the extratropics as well. The multimodel RPSS skill of both precipitation and temperature is shown to exceed that of any of the constituent models over Indonesia, South Asia, South America, and East Africa in all seasons. An example real-time week-3–4 global forecast for 13–26 November 2021 is illustrated and shown to bear the hallmarks of the combined influences of a moderate Madden–Julian oscillation event as well as weak–moderate ongoing La Niña event.
Significance Statement
This paper develops a system for forecasting of precipitation and temperatures globally over land, several weeks in advance, with a focus on biweekly averaged conditions between three and four weeks ahead. The system provides the likelihood of biweekly and weekly conditions being below, near, or above their long-term averages, as well the probability of exceeding (or not exceeding) any threshold value. Using historical data, the precipitation forecasts are demonstrated to have skill in many tropical regions, and the temperature forecasts are more widely skillful. While weather and seasonal range forecasts have become quite generally available, this is one of the first examples of a publicly available, calibrated multimodel probabilistic real-time forecasting system for the subseasonal range.
Abstract
This study presents an initial demonstration of assimilating small uncrewed aircraft system (sUAS) data into an operational model with a goal to ultimately improve tropical cyclone (TC) analyses and forecasts. The observations, obtained using the Coyote sUAS in Hurricane Maria (2017), were assimilated into the operational Hurricane Weather Research and Forecast (HWRF) system as they could be in operations. Results suggest that the Coyote data can benefit HWRF forecasts. A single-cycle case study produced the best results when the Coyote observations were assimilated at greater horizontal resolution with more relaxed quality control (QC) than comparable flight-level high-density observations currently used in operations. The case study results guided experiments that cycled HWRF for a roughly 4-day period that covered all Coyote flights into Maria. The cycled experiment that assimilated the most data improved initial inner-core structure in the analyses and better agreed with other aircraft observations. The average errors in track and intensity decreased in the subsequent forecasts. Intensity forecasts were too weak when no Coyote data were assimilated, and assimilating the Coyote data made the forecasts stronger. Results also suggest that a symmetric distribution of Coyote data around the TC center is necessary to maximize its benefits in the current configuration of operational HWRF. Although the sample size was limited, these experiments provide insight for potential operational use of data from newer sUAS platforms in future TC applications.
Significance Statement
This study represents the first time that observations from a small uncrewed aircraft system (sUAS) have been assimilated into an operational numerical model. Including these data was shown to have potential for improving forecasts of tropical cyclone track and intensity. The data were obtained using the Coyote sUAS, but these results are expected to be applicable to newer platforms that will be operational soon.
Abstract
This study presents an initial demonstration of assimilating small uncrewed aircraft system (sUAS) data into an operational model with a goal to ultimately improve tropical cyclone (TC) analyses and forecasts. The observations, obtained using the Coyote sUAS in Hurricane Maria (2017), were assimilated into the operational Hurricane Weather Research and Forecast (HWRF) system as they could be in operations. Results suggest that the Coyote data can benefit HWRF forecasts. A single-cycle case study produced the best results when the Coyote observations were assimilated at greater horizontal resolution with more relaxed quality control (QC) than comparable flight-level high-density observations currently used in operations. The case study results guided experiments that cycled HWRF for a roughly 4-day period that covered all Coyote flights into Maria. The cycled experiment that assimilated the most data improved initial inner-core structure in the analyses and better agreed with other aircraft observations. The average errors in track and intensity decreased in the subsequent forecasts. Intensity forecasts were too weak when no Coyote data were assimilated, and assimilating the Coyote data made the forecasts stronger. Results also suggest that a symmetric distribution of Coyote data around the TC center is necessary to maximize its benefits in the current configuration of operational HWRF. Although the sample size was limited, these experiments provide insight for potential operational use of data from newer sUAS platforms in future TC applications.
Significance Statement
This study represents the first time that observations from a small uncrewed aircraft system (sUAS) have been assimilated into an operational numerical model. Including these data was shown to have potential for improving forecasts of tropical cyclone track and intensity. The data were obtained using the Coyote sUAS, but these results are expected to be applicable to newer platforms that will be operational soon.
Abstract
The ability of high-resolution mesoscale models to simulate near-surface and subsurface meteorological processes is critical for representing land–atmosphere feedback processes. The High-Resolution Rapid Refresh (HRRR) model is a 3-km numerical weather prediction model that has been used operationally since 2014. In this study, we evaluated the HRRR over the contiguous United States from 1 January 2021 to 31 December 2021. We compared the 1-, 3-, 6-, 12-, 18-, 24-, 30-, and 48-h forecasts against observations of air and surface temperature, shortwave radiation, and soil temperature and moisture from the 114 stations of the U.S. Climate Reference Network (USCRN) and evaluated the HRRR’s performance for different geographic regions and land cover types. We found that the HRRR well simulated air and surface temperatures, but underestimated soil temperatures when temperatures were subfreezing. The HRRR had the largest overestimates in shortwave radiation under cloudy skies, and there was a positive relationship between the shortwave radiation mean bias error (MBE) and air temperature MBE that was stronger in summer than winter. Additionally, the HRRR underestimated soil moisture when the values exceeded about 0.2 m3 m−3, but overestimated soil moisture when measurements were below this value. Consequently, the HRRR exhibited a positive soil moisture MBE over the drier areas of the western United States and a negative MBE over the eastern United States. Although caution is needed when applying conclusions regarding HRRR’s biases to locations with subgrid-scale land cover variations, general knowledge of HRRR’s biases will help guide improvements to land surface models used in high-resolution weather forecasting models.
Significance Statement
Weather forecasters rely upon output from many different models. However, the models’ ability to represent processes happening near the land surface over short time scales is critical for producing accurate weather forecasts. In this study, we evaluated the High-Resolution Rapid Refresh (HRRR) model using observations from the U.S. Climate Reference Network, which currently includes 114 reference climate observing stations in the contiguous United States. These stations provide highly accurate measurements of air temperature, precipitation, soil temperature, and soil moisture. Our findings helped illustrate conditions when the HRRR performs well, but also conditions in which the HRRR can be improved, which we expect will motivate ongoing improvements to the HRRR and other weather forecasting models.
Abstract
The ability of high-resolution mesoscale models to simulate near-surface and subsurface meteorological processes is critical for representing land–atmosphere feedback processes. The High-Resolution Rapid Refresh (HRRR) model is a 3-km numerical weather prediction model that has been used operationally since 2014. In this study, we evaluated the HRRR over the contiguous United States from 1 January 2021 to 31 December 2021. We compared the 1-, 3-, 6-, 12-, 18-, 24-, 30-, and 48-h forecasts against observations of air and surface temperature, shortwave radiation, and soil temperature and moisture from the 114 stations of the U.S. Climate Reference Network (USCRN) and evaluated the HRRR’s performance for different geographic regions and land cover types. We found that the HRRR well simulated air and surface temperatures, but underestimated soil temperatures when temperatures were subfreezing. The HRRR had the largest overestimates in shortwave radiation under cloudy skies, and there was a positive relationship between the shortwave radiation mean bias error (MBE) and air temperature MBE that was stronger in summer than winter. Additionally, the HRRR underestimated soil moisture when the values exceeded about 0.2 m3 m−3, but overestimated soil moisture when measurements were below this value. Consequently, the HRRR exhibited a positive soil moisture MBE over the drier areas of the western United States and a negative MBE over the eastern United States. Although caution is needed when applying conclusions regarding HRRR’s biases to locations with subgrid-scale land cover variations, general knowledge of HRRR’s biases will help guide improvements to land surface models used in high-resolution weather forecasting models.
Significance Statement
Weather forecasters rely upon output from many different models. However, the models’ ability to represent processes happening near the land surface over short time scales is critical for producing accurate weather forecasts. In this study, we evaluated the High-Resolution Rapid Refresh (HRRR) model using observations from the U.S. Climate Reference Network, which currently includes 114 reference climate observing stations in the contiguous United States. These stations provide highly accurate measurements of air temperature, precipitation, soil temperature, and soil moisture. Our findings helped illustrate conditions when the HRRR performs well, but also conditions in which the HRRR can be improved, which we expect will motivate ongoing improvements to the HRRR and other weather forecasting models.
Abstract
In operational weather forecasting, it is effective to aggregate information on all members of an ensemble forecast through cluster analysis. The temporal coherence of ensemble members in each cluster is an important piece of information about the robustness of the forecast scenario given by clusters. This information is especially important for forecasts for which the target area is a city or prefecture, that is, an Eulerian framework, because the members that compose each cluster can change over time because of the small size of the target area. This study provided the temporal coherence of members in clusters by performing principal component analysis and cluster analysis on 3-hourly 500-hPa geopotential height forecasts and linking the clustering results in the time direction. The new method provided a consistently well-divided forecast scenario throughout the forecast period for Eulerian frame forecasts, as well as information on the temporal coherency of the members in the clusters, which was demonstrated to be effective through the experiment to preselect a cluster with small errors. The application of the new technique to improve precipitation forecasts was also discussed.
Significance Statement
Numerical weather forecasts always contain errors. Although the uncertainty of such forecasts cannot be obtained from the forecast itself, ensemble forecasts, which are aggregates of many forecasts, can be used to estimate the uncertainty of the forecast. In this study, a new method was developed to transfer the information contained in many ensemble forecasts into four forecasts by cluster analysis and to provide forecast information suitable for a small forecasting area such as a prefecture. The use of this method for improving precipitation forecasts was also examined.
Abstract
In operational weather forecasting, it is effective to aggregate information on all members of an ensemble forecast through cluster analysis. The temporal coherence of ensemble members in each cluster is an important piece of information about the robustness of the forecast scenario given by clusters. This information is especially important for forecasts for which the target area is a city or prefecture, that is, an Eulerian framework, because the members that compose each cluster can change over time because of the small size of the target area. This study provided the temporal coherence of members in clusters by performing principal component analysis and cluster analysis on 3-hourly 500-hPa geopotential height forecasts and linking the clustering results in the time direction. The new method provided a consistently well-divided forecast scenario throughout the forecast period for Eulerian frame forecasts, as well as information on the temporal coherency of the members in the clusters, which was demonstrated to be effective through the experiment to preselect a cluster with small errors. The application of the new technique to improve precipitation forecasts was also discussed.
Significance Statement
Numerical weather forecasts always contain errors. Although the uncertainty of such forecasts cannot be obtained from the forecast itself, ensemble forecasts, which are aggregates of many forecasts, can be used to estimate the uncertainty of the forecast. In this study, a new method was developed to transfer the information contained in many ensemble forecasts into four forecasts by cluster analysis and to provide forecast information suitable for a small forecasting area such as a prefecture. The use of this method for improving precipitation forecasts was also examined.
