A Reexamination of Homogeneous Nucleation Theory

C. S. Kiang Clark College Research Group, Physics Dept., Clark College, Atlanta, Ga

Search for other papers by C. S. Kiang in
Current site
Google Scholar
PubMed
Close
,
D. Stauffer Clark College Research Group, Physics Dept., Clark College, Atlanta, Ga

Search for other papers by D. Stauffer in
Current site
Google Scholar
PubMed
Close
,
G. H. Walker Clark College Research Group, Physics Dept., Clark College, Atlanta, Ga

Search for other papers by G. H. Walker in
Current site
Google Scholar
PubMed
Close
,
O. P. Puri Clark College Research Group, Physics Dept., Clark College, Atlanta, Ga

Search for other papers by O. P. Puri in
Current site
Google Scholar
PubMed
Close
,
J. D. Wise Jr. Clark College Research Group, Physics Dept., Clark College, Atlanta, Ga

Search for other papers by J. D. Wise Jr. in
Current site
Google Scholar
PubMed
Close
, and
E. M. Patterson Clark College Research Group, Physics Dept., Clark College, Atlanta, Ga

Search for other papers by E. M. Patterson in
Current site
Google Scholar
PubMed
Close
Full access

Abstract

The homogeneous nucleation theory of liquid droplets in supersaturated vapors is reviewed. Taking into consideration the microscopic surface tension and extrapolating from the triple point to the critical point (T = Te) of the liquid-gas phase transition, we reexamine homogeneous nucleation theory. A calculation of the growth rate for microscopic clusters due to the incorporation of much smaller clusters (instead of single molecules) is given and an appropriate variable, scaled supersaturation, is presented to study the mechanism of homogeneous nucleation. For a given nucleation rate, the scaled supersaturation is expected to be nearly independent of temperature below Te.; this is confirmed by experimental data. A generalized form for the droplet model is proposed. Previous theories (“classical,” Lothe-Pound, Reiss, Katz, Cohen) are shown to be special cases of this generalized form and all are shown to be invalid near the critical point. A quantitative theory is made by extrapolating Fisher's droplet model from the critical region to the triple point. For the free energy of embryo formation we include the contributions due to internal vibrations and self-avoiding walks. The microscopic surface tension for the droplet is estimated from the measured coexistence curve; it is found to agree with the bulk macroscopic surface tension near the triple and critical points and to be smaller in the intermediate region. With these considerations we have calculated the scaled supersaturation for water vapor as a function of temperature for given measured nucleation rates. The proposed theory is in good agreement with experiment.

Abstract

The homogeneous nucleation theory of liquid droplets in supersaturated vapors is reviewed. Taking into consideration the microscopic surface tension and extrapolating from the triple point to the critical point (T = Te) of the liquid-gas phase transition, we reexamine homogeneous nucleation theory. A calculation of the growth rate for microscopic clusters due to the incorporation of much smaller clusters (instead of single molecules) is given and an appropriate variable, scaled supersaturation, is presented to study the mechanism of homogeneous nucleation. For a given nucleation rate, the scaled supersaturation is expected to be nearly independent of temperature below Te.; this is confirmed by experimental data. A generalized form for the droplet model is proposed. Previous theories (“classical,” Lothe-Pound, Reiss, Katz, Cohen) are shown to be special cases of this generalized form and all are shown to be invalid near the critical point. A quantitative theory is made by extrapolating Fisher's droplet model from the critical region to the triple point. For the free energy of embryo formation we include the contributions due to internal vibrations and self-avoiding walks. The microscopic surface tension for the droplet is estimated from the measured coexistence curve; it is found to agree with the bulk macroscopic surface tension near the triple and critical points and to be smaller in the intermediate region. With these considerations we have calculated the scaled supersaturation for water vapor as a function of temperature for given measured nucleation rates. The proposed theory is in good agreement with experiment.

Save